COMMUNICATION WITH AIIB

Joint Gender Statement to AIIB

JIN LIQUN

President

Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank

B9 Financial Street, Xicheng District Beijing 10033

People’s Republic of China

 

Copied to:

Dr. D.J. Pandian, Vice President and Chief Investment Officer

Dr. Joachim von Amsberg, Vice President – Policy and Strategy

Mr. Hamid Sharif, Compliance, Effectiveness and Integrity Unit (CEIU) Director General

Ms. Laurel Ostfield, Head of Communications and Development

Mr. Oliver Barron, Executive Officer, Office of the President

Ms. Michaela Bergman, Principal Social Development Specialist Members of the Board of Directors of the AIIB

 

CSO Joint Statement to AIIB on Gender

 

Dear Pres. Jin,

 

In the Asia – Pacific and beyond, the role of gender equality and women’s rights in the achievement of development goals at the individual, household, community, workforce, and societal levels cannot be understated. The extent of power, influence, and resources of international financial institutions (IFIs) including the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) to reduce or impose structural barriers to women’s economic rights cannot be ignored. In the past, civil society organizations have documented that IFI – led projects and policies have resulted in a gender-unequal distribution of unpaid care work and access to healthcare facilities, schools, and livelihood opportunities.

In the case of some sovereign ADB – funded projects particularly the Khulna - Jessore Drainage Project in Bangladesh project – affected women were not included in meaningful consultations and design of the said Project. None of the resettled women were able to found employment opportunities related to the Cambodia Railway Rehabilitation Project. The specific measures to ensure women had access to vocational training or saving groups were also not implemented. Similarly in the ADB – financed Kolkata Environmental Project an estimate of 2,880 affected households mostly canal bank dwellers were displaced. Some of the affected families were given a flat measuring 15.5 ft by 10 ft. The small size of these flats led to several difficulties such as girls married off earlier as there was a small space for them to stay and indirect harassment among others. In these cases, women and girls often experience twice the burden of the unintended and adverse impacts of poorly designed IFI – funded projects This has resulted in gender discrimination as well as gender - unequal social and economic power relationships.

 

The large-scale investments by IFIs often change not only entire economies but of societies too. AIIB and its co-financiers pledge support into building large-scale infrastructure such as road, railways, high voltage transmission lines, and power – sector stations. This also expands to special economic zones along the stretches of the so-called infrastructure corridors. The land being used in support for local livelihoods such as for food production is now claimed for infrastructure and production halls.

 

As a result, women have less and lesser access to land and natural resources. Their livelihoods, which used to depend on land and natural resources, are becoming increasingly dependent on temporary lowly paid jobs in the economic zones and corridors. Such practices impose threats and risks where labor standards are applied much more loosely than what national laws dictate. Economic development that is based on the extraction of natural resources and exploitation of laborers is unlikely to bring positive change for women’s economic independence and equality.

 

In 2015, World Bank developed its new Gender Strategy for 2016 – 2023. However, its Environment and Social Framework even in conjunction with the Guidance Notes are still inadequate to reflect the bank’s gender commitments at the project level implementation. Whereas in the case of the ADB, the 2009 Safeguard Policy Statement include requirements for gender considerations with regards to project impact and risk assessment, an involvement of women and gender considerations in consultations as well as requirements for gender sensitive and responsive grievance mechanism. However, there is still the absence of binding gender safeguards and lack of assessment on how these gender considerations are implemented to ensure the protection and participation of women in all phases of the project cycle.

 

AIIB as a new IFI established in 2016 has an opportunity to set the bar higher than other IFIs towards a more progressive approach towards safeguards and protection of women both at the policy and project implementation level. Gender considerations should also be reflected particularly for private sector-led operations, which have been criticised for its lesser accountability and transparency measures. It is in these contexts, that we CSOs demand that gender - intersectional issues such as resettlement/displacement and loss of livelihoods, particularly affecting women and girl – children, be integrated into all policies and project implementation. Project – affected women have also absorbed severe adverse impacts of poor project implementation and exclusion from meaningful consultations. To remedy this, AIIB investments and policies must strengthen the implementation of gender perspectives and ensure gender – responsive and inclusive infrastructure development financing. As civil society organizations, we urge the AIIB to mandatorily require that all Bank policies and operations identify and prevent potential gender discrimination against project – affected persons, particularly women, and prevent women’s suffering from forced displacement, loss of livelihoods and gender injustices.

Specifically, we ask AIIB to:

 

1. Protect project-affected households, particularly women and girls, from project risks and impacts.

The AIIB commitment to “sustainable growth” had identified that it will ensure safe and healthy working conditions for all workers, promote gender equality, encourage inclusive development and empower vulnerable groups. However, to guarantee that the AIIB consistently promotes gender equality it should ensure the protection of women and mainstream gender issues by identifying and addressing potential and actual gender disparities in the implementation of AIIB – financed projects. Project – affected women should not be viewed merely as oppressed victims but as rights – holders and significant stakeholders in decision – making processes. Lastly, AIIB policies should uphold the protection of project – affected peoples, especially women and girls, against direct and indirect sexual harassment.

 

2. Develop a strong Directive on the Environmental and Social Policy (ESP) with gender considerations.

In the AIIB’s Environment and Social Framework (ESF), it highlights the importance of gender equality i.e. “the Bank recognizes the importance of gender equality for successful and sustainable economic development and the need for inclusiveness and gender responsiveness in the Projects it supports (para. 14).” However a close scrutiny on the 4 – page Directive on Environmental and Social Policy which “aims to facilitate the implementation of the Bank’s ESP, including the Environmental and Social Standards (ESS)” clearly shows the absence of how to operationalize the commitments and gender considerations identified in the Policy. The Policy provides for: A “gender – sensitive, culturally appropriate and readily accessible project-level grievance redress mechanism to all affected people (para. 63); Gender was also identified in the conduct of an environment and social assessment for the proposed Project in identifying direct, indirect, cumulative and induced risks and impacts (on ESS 1: Environment and Social Assessment and Management); Describes a meaningful consultation that is gender inclusive, accessible, responsive and tailored to the needs of vulnerable groups (on ESS 1); Taking gender into account in conducting the planning for involuntary resettlement through the survey of land and assets, full census of persons to be displaced and evaluation of socio- economic conditions specifically related to involuntary resettlement risks and impacts (on ESS 2: Involuntary Resettlement); and Undertake a culturally appropriate and gender-sensitive social assessment (on ESS 3: Indigenous Peoples). Despite these provisions in the Policy, the application of gender mainstreaming particularly in operationalizing the ESP through the Directive is hardly visible, if not entirely non – existent. This might be a case of “gender evaporation” where gender considerations are integrated into the Policy and rhetoric but might possibly disappear in the actual implementation of projects. Local community and other stakeholder consultations should have balanced representation by women and men.

 

3. The AIIB should develop a mechanism to strengthen the capacity of its Clients to implement the gender considerations identified in the ESF and Policy. The ESF provides that the “Bank supports its Clients to identify potential gender-specific opportunities as well as gender-specific adverse risks and impacts under their Projects and to develop mitigation measures to avoid or reduce such impacts and risks.” Furthermore, it also encourages Clients to enhance the design of their Projects in an inclusive and gender- responsive manner to promote equality of opportunity and women’s socio-economic empowerment (para. 14) [Note: Emphasis supplied].” This language essentially places the onus to the Clients whether or not they will implement the gender considerations identified in the ESF and Policy. To further ensure the seriousness of the Bank in recognizing the significance of gender equality, it should also develop the capacity building of its Clients to adhere to and implement these gender considerations. The AIIB should also strengthen its due diligence and oversight in ensuring that women be involved in meaningful participation and consultations related to all project stage processes from identification and design of feasibility studies prior to Board approval, to planning, implementation, monitoring, and evaluation. This should also include the identification and assessment of existing and new technologies for projects to improve the condition of women. The AIIB should also integrate women’s experiences and knowledge into both policy and project implementation.

 

4. Mandatorily collect gender-disaggregated baseline and monitoring data from project identification to completion stages.  The AIIB provides that, “Where relevant, use gender-disaggregated data and analysis and consider enhancing the design of the Project to promote equality of opportunity and women’s socio-economic empowerment (on ESS 1) [Note: Emphasis supplied].” While this is not the opportune time to consider any changes in the language of the ESF and Policy, the AIIB should exercise due diligence over its Clients in the implementation of collecting gender disaggregated baseline and monitoring data at all project stages particularly during the identification of project – affected persons. This would further ensure gender - equal sharing of project benefits and opportunities. Similarly, this would ensure that the identified mitigation measured adequately responds to the needs of the project – affected women.

 

5. As AIIB is beginning to finance more stand-alone infrastructure projects, its ESF delivery by its borrowers and clients on gender dimensions, issues and obligations will be expected to meet due diligence delivery and compliance.  The AIIB is also obligated to ensure the necessary steps for monitoring and oversight of its clients. As such AIIB policies as a requirement for the Banks client to meet, should uphold international human right frameworks and standards including Convention on the Discrimination of all forms Against Women (CEDAW) and develop measures to ensure the safety and security of the women in communities and women environmental defenders.

 

Contributors:

Aksi Indonesia

ActionAid India

American Friends Service Committee, Myanmar

Asian Peoples Movement on Debt and Development (APMDD)

Bank Information Center USA

 

Signatories:

BothENDS

Climate Watch Thailand

Centre for Environmental Justice, Sri Lanka

Centre for Development and Research Action, India

Coastal Livelihood and Environmental Action Network (CLEAN), Bangladesh

Environics, India

Indian Social Action Forum (INSAF)

Gender Action

Greenwatershed, China

Nash Vek, Kyrgyzstan

NGO Forum on ADB

Oxfam

Paung Ku

Myanmar Programme on Women's Economic Social and Cultural Rights (PWESCR)

Solidaritas Perempuan, Indonesia

Action Paysanne Contre La Faim

Democratic Republic of the Congo

Bank Information Center Europe, Europe

BRICS Feminist Watch

International Center for International Environmental Law

International Community Empowerment and Social Justice Foundation

Nepal Conectas Human Rights, Brazil Conseil Regional des Organisations Non Gouvernementales de Developpement, Democratic Republic of the Congo

Crude Accountability 

International Echoes of Women in African Initiatives, Nigeria

Friends of the Earth, USA

International Rivers

International Oyu Tolgoi Watch, Mongolia

Radha Paudel Foundation, Nepal

Rivers without Boundaries, Mongolia

Youth for Environment Education and Development Foundation, Nepal

 

Download letter here.

Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank’s (AIIB) Paper on the Accountability Framework: Reflections from Civil Society

10 September 2018

 

JIN LIQUN

President
Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank B9 Financial Street, Xicheng District Beijing 10033 People’s Republic of China

 

Copied to:
Dr. Joachim von Amsberg, Vice President – Policy and Strategy
Mr. Hamid Sharif, Compliance, Effectiveness and Integrity Unit (CEIU) Director General Dr. Somnath Basu, Senior Social Development Specialist
Ms. Laurel Ostfield, Head of Communications and Development
Members of the Board of Directors of the AIIB

 

Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank’s (AIIB) Paper on the Accountability Framework: Reflections from Civil Society

 

The Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank’s Accountability Framework should be analyzed and monitored simultaneously alongside the provisions set forth on the Paper, Regulation and the Decision on the said Framework1. The Paper was adopted on 11 April 2018 and the Regulation shall be effective by 1 January 2019.

We re-echo our 6 April 2018 input sent to the AIIB that, “This decision goes to the heart of the question of governance at the Bank. Board members are accountable to their constituent governments, shareholders of the AIIB, for their decisions. Shareholder governments in turn are responsible to their citizens for ensuring that the Bank upholds its environmental and social standards in its lending operations. In essence, the project approval process by the Board provides an opportunity for civil society and potentially affected communities to raise their concerns with their representatives, to ensure decisions are well-informed and take account of potential harms."

 

NGO FORUM ON ADB STATEMENT TO PRESIDENT JIN LIQUN AND THE MANAGEMENT 2nd ANNUAL GOVERNORS’ MEETING, CSO Dialogue Session

GOOD AFTERNOON, President Jin Liqun, Members of the Management, Ladies, and Gentlemen.

 

On behalf of the members of NGO Forum on ADB, we congratulate you on this occasion of AIIB’s 2nd Annual Governors’ Meeting. This dialogue with you is most welcome for it gives us the opportunity to raise some important issues from the communities that we work with across the region.

 

As a strong civil society network from the South engaging with the Banks in Asia, the NGO Forum on ADB and our community partners have been monitoring ADB programs and projects for over twenty years. Our memberships’ long engagement with ADB provides us the experience to support and back up our analysis on AIIB’s current policies and implementation of its projects. As the Bank continues with its operations beyond the 2nd AGM, it would be vital to take a step back and see how things stand and where it is heading to. 

 

Proposed AIIB Energy Sector Strategy

See the AIIB Proposed Energy Sector Strategy

1 / 5

Please reload

© 2019 by NGO Forum on ADB

  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • Instagram Social Icon
  • YouTube Social  Icon
  • Google+ Social Icon

85-A Masikap Extension, Diliman, Quezon City, Philippines | +632 436-1858 | +632 921-4412 | secretariat@forum-adb.org