top of page

NGO Forum on ADB Points for Consideration on the ADB Accountability Mechanism Policy Review Draft

11 hours ago
4 min read

Policy Review Process

From the Forum, we urge the ADB to ensure that the draft ADB AM Policy paper is released after the 2026 year-end holidays; releasing the draft in the December holiday season will not lead to robust inputs from CSOs working on the ADB AM issue, as they will also be on leave during the holidays. The commenting period should be respected in its entirety during circulation. We recommend that the draft policy be released in the new year in 2027 so that the maximum number of working days across the region is utilized in gathering views from all external stakeholders.


Project Related Information (Access and Reliability)

 ADB must ensure that all project documents, reports, and summaries uploaded on the ADB website should not be removed or edited once uploaded. As the information needs to be valid and reliable for AM case filing.

  • The formal loan cut-off date must be publicized in the project data sheet, and any changes or caveats must be indicated to establish a fairly uncontroversial fact in aid of possible complaints filing. 

  • AM Cases deemed ineligible for falling outside the scope of the AM (procurement issues, for example) must be indicated as such in the AM site. 


On Good Faith Efforts

  • In case of non-functioning Grievance Redress Mechanisms GRMs at the project level, the good faith efforts for complainants must be exempted. 

  • Consequently, clear prescriptive timelines must be placed on Management response to complainants. In case of Management responses being delayed beyond a clearly prescribed time limit (for example, 20 days), the Good Faith Effort requirement criteria must be exempted.

  • In cases of proven risk of retaliation (to be verified independently by the Accountability Mechanism) to communities in accessing GRMs or reaching out to ADB management, the Good Faith Efforts criteria must be exempted.

  • Exemption from good faith efforts should be granted for egregious or extraordinary harms, for both anticipated and unanticipated harms, but especially for unanticipated harms not outlined in the environmental impact statement (EIS) or initial impact examination (IEE) but which resulted from the project, and which could therefore blindside an affected community. 

  • For the points above, the arbitration and assessment must be under the jurisdiction of the Accountability Mechanism itself, in consultation with the complainants.


Prescription Period for Complaints of Harms   

Some harms are only apparent well beyond the two-year prescription for filing. Especially for egregious harms, the AM must investigate the cause of harm and provide for loss and damage compensation even outside the two-year rule. In case of long-term environmental and transboundary harms, evidence of adverse impacts may appear beyond the two-year time limit as well as beyond the project site ( transboundary air pollution, maritime pollution and impact on biodiversity, groundwater pollution, surface runoff pollution, radioactive contamination, etc.)


AM response to reprisals

Complaints which evidence risk of retaliation and reprisals must be handled by the CRP exclusively, ensuring absolute anonymity of the affected communities with utmost sensitivity and urgency. 

 

Period of Resolution and Remedy

Resolution of cases, and especially the awarding of compensation, must be mandated after a certain reasonable period of adjudication. The AM must have the ability to secure additional human and financial resources in aid of speedy resolutions. 

 

Remedial Action Plan Monitoring

The Accountability Mechanism is designed to provide remedies for harms identified by complainants that have been deemed eligible for investigation after filing. To this end, the Remedial Action Plan (RAP), which is the solution to the harm after the investigation process, is the last-mile solution. The Accountability Mechanism must have oversight of the implementation of the RAPs. There should be a feedback loop between the original complainants and the AM, with oversight and monitoring of the RAP, to ensure the remedy plan is being implemented properly to mitigate the harms raised in the complaint. This entails on-field and on-site monitoring of the implementation of the RAP by the AM, with clear reporting lines for the monitoring to the Board of Directors of the ADB.There must be local representation for the communities involved in complaint filing processes. Local and national civil society organisations will have a better understanding of local contexts, local politics, and risks during the complaint process. Local civil society organisations may work with regional and international organisations, with the clear consent of the affected community complainants, during the complaint process. If no local representatives are available, regional and international organisations may represent complainants in the process.


Procedural Guidance and Policy Implementation Rules

The new ADB AM policy must also include a separate document which will elaborate Rules of Implementation and/or Procedural Guidance for the policy to be implemented in practice. The procedural guidance should explicitly identify all the details in complaint filing, investigation, and remedial action plan implementation. There should be clearly identified timings of various steps, information disclosure and decision-making guidance, along with clear procedures outlining all aspects of an investigation and remedial action plan monitoring. 


We also strongly recommend that the ADB Accountability Mechanism will be exclusively in charge of drafting the Procedural Guidance and/or Implementation Rules for the New ADB AM Policy without any interference from ADB Management, OGC, or Operations to avoid any conflict of interest.


We hope you will kindly consider the above points with utmost sincerity for your deliberation over the new draft ADB AM Policy.


Sincerely,


Rayyan Hassan

Executive Director

NGO Forum on ADB

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page